Nikolai Bukharin vs Prakash Karat

Bukharin became editor of Pravda, the Bolshevik newspaper, in 1917. He used the platform to advocate for radical socialist policies, including the immediate nationalization of industry and opposition to the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, shaping early Bolshevik ideology.

Bukharin published 'Economics of the Transition Period', a theoretical work arguing for the necessity of state capitalism and forced industrialization during the transition to socialism. The book influenced early Soviet economic policy and debates on the NEP.

Bukharin led the Right Opposition within the Communist Party, opposing Stalin's forced collectivization and rapid industrialization policies. He advocated for a continuation of the NEP and a more gradual approach, but was defeated and removed from power by 1929.

Bukharin was tried in the third Moscow Show Trial in March 1938, accused of espionage, sabotage, and plotting to restore capitalism. Despite a vigorous defense, he was found guilty and executed on March 15, 1938, becoming one of the last prominent Old Bolsheviks purged.

Prakash Karat was elected General Secretary of CPI(M), succeeding Harkishan Singh Surjeet. He led the party during the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government, supporting it from outside.

Karat led the CPI(M) to withdraw support from the UPA government over the Indo-US civilian nuclear agreement, which the party opposed as a threat to India's sovereignty. This led to a confidence vote that the government survived.

Karat published this book critiquing the India-US nuclear deal and its implications for India's foreign policy. The book argued that the deal made India a subordinate ally of the US.