Tokugawa Ieyasu leads by 17.7 pts · 2 figures compared

General · Medieval

General · Modern
Saladin's forces defeated the Crusader army at Hattin, near Tiberias. He captured King Guy of Jerusalem and the True Cross relic. The victory decimated the Crusader military and opened the way for the recapture of Jerusalem.
Saladin's army besieged and captured Jerusalem from the Crusaders after 88 years of Christian rule. He allowed the inhabitants to leave peacefully or be ransomed, contrasting with the Crusaders' massacre in 1099. This event triggered the Third Crusade.
Saladin faced a prolonged siege of Acre by Crusader forces under Richard the Lionheart and Philip Augustus. After nearly two years, the city fell to the Crusaders. Saladin's inability to relieve the siege was a major setback.
Saladin's forces attacked Richard the Lionheart's army marching south from Acre. Richard's disciplined infantry repelled the attacks, inflicting heavy losses on Saladin's troops. The battle ended in a tactical Crusader victory, but Saladin's army remained intact.
Saladin and Richard the Lionheart signed the Treaty of Ramla, ending the Third Crusade. The treaty granted Crusaders control of a coastal strip from Jaffa to Acre, while Muslims retained Jerusalem. Christian pilgrims were allowed access to holy sites.
Tokugawa Ieyasu led the Eastern Army to victory over Ishida Mitsunari's Western Army at Sekigahara. This decisive battle ended the Sengoku period and established Ieyasu as the supreme military ruler of Japan, paving the way for the Tokugawa shogunate.
Emperor Go-Yozei appointed Tokugawa Ieyasu as shogun, officially beginning the Tokugawa shogunate. Ieyasu established his government in Edo (modern Tokyo), centralizing military and political power under his family's control.
Tokugawa Ieyasu besieged Osaka Castle, the stronghold of Toyotomi Hideyori. The castle fell, and Hideyori committed suicide. This campaign eliminated the last major opposition to Tokugawa rule, solidifying the shogunate's control over Japan.
Ieyasu issued the Laws for the Military Houses, a code regulating the conduct of daimyo. It restricted castle construction, required alternate attendance in Edo, and prohibited alliances without shogunal permission. This law helped control the feudal lords.
In his final years, Ieyasu began policies that led to Japan's isolation. He restricted foreign trade to specific ports and expelled Christian missionaries. These measures, expanded by successors, resulted in the sakoku policy that isolated Japan for over 200 years.
Each figure is scored on 6 dimensions (0—100 scale) based on structured historical data: Military (10%), Political (20%), Influence (20%), Legacy (20%), Leadership (15%), Strategy (15%). The weighted total produces the final ranking.
Scores are computed from structured sub-indicators in the database. Scale factors adjust for era (Ancient ×0.85, Modern ×1.0) and civilization size (Eastern ×1.05, Other ×0.80) to account for differences in population and military scale.
Comparisons are limited to 2—3 figures to ensure readability and statistical meaningfulness.
±5 points per dimension — Sub-scores are derived from historical records with inherent uncertainty. Two figures within 5 points on a dimension should be considered roughly equivalent in that area.
±3 points overall — The weighted combination of 6 dimensions produces a total score with approximately ±3 points of uncertainty. Differences of less than 3 points are not statistically significant— the figures are effectively tied.
This comparison buys too heavily into the 'great man' narrative. Saladin's chivalry gets romanticized by Western historians because he was a noble enemy — and that's exactly the problem. It erases the fact that he was fighting a colonial invasion, not some honorable duel. Meanwhile, Tokugawa Ieyasu's 'stable' shogunate came at the cost of closing Japan off from the world, enforcing a rigid caste system, and persecuting Christians. Calling him the better leader ignores how his legacy includes cultural stagnation and state violence. If we rated these figures from the perspective of the people they conquered, Saladin looks like a liberator and Ieyasu like a tyrant. The scores reflect a Western-centric, pro-establishment bias.
这个评分很有意思,但明显带有西方中心论的偏见。萨拉丁的军事分82分高于德川家康的78分,可家康在关原之战中以八万兵力击败石田三成的十万大军,其战术调度和后勤能力一点都不逊色。更关键的是,家康的治国能力——建立幕府、实施士农工商等级制、锁国政策维持260年和平——这些放在中国历史上,堪比秦始皇统一六国后的制度建设。萨拉丁死后帝国分裂,而家康的德川幕府长期稳定,这才是顶级政治家的体现。总分80.7对73.5,我觉得还是低估了家康。
我重新算了一下权重。萨拉丁军事82,政治72,这其实有矛盾:如果他的军事行动靠的是联合埃及、叙利亚的盟友,那政治统合能力应该更高才对。家康政治82分,但他在大阪冬之阵中诱使丰臣家开城,之后又撕毁和约发动夏之阵,这种政治手腕放在中国历史上,堪比刘邦对韩信的算计。另外,影响力维度家康75分低于萨拉丁的72分?萨拉丁主要是靠西方浪漫化叙事加分,家康的锁国政策直接塑造了江户时代的社会结构,影响更深远。如果按我对中国历代开国君主的权重分配(政治40%、军事30%、影响30%),家康总分应该在83分左右。